top_2_1.jpg top_2_2.jpg
Discretion in Criminal Justice
The Tension Between Individualization and Uniformity
Discretion in Criminal Justice
Click on image to enlarge

Lloyd E. Ohlin - Editor
Frank J. Remington - Editor
SUNY series in New Directions in Crime and Justice Studies
Price: $95.00 
Hardcover - 365 pages
Release Date: August 1993
ISBN10: 0-7914-1563-5
ISBN13: 978-0-7914-1563-4

Price: $33.95 
Paperback - 365 pages
Release Date: August 1993
ISBN10: 0-7914-1564-3
ISBN13: 978-0-7914-1564-1

Available as a Google eBook
for other eReaders and tablet devices.
Click icon below...

Summary Read First Chapter image missing

"In the 1950s the American Bar Foundation conducted a pilot survey of the processing of offenders from arrest to prison--to observe what actually happened at each decision point, instead of assuming that doctrinal legal analyses were sufficient. This book consists of original, authoritative, and well written essays by leading scholars in law and criminal justice, who worked on the ABF project. All, including the editors, are among the most eminent figures in criminal law and procedures, criminal justice, and the law and society movement. Each contributor provides a wealth of insights and information regarding the famous pre-ABF crime surveys, the ABF studies themselves, and post-ABF research." -- Austin Turk, University of California-Riverside

"It is a fascinating retrospective account of the research done decades ago by the American Bar Foundation's Survey of Criminal Justice. Many of the chief participants in that multi-volume Survey write here about the consequences of the earlier research for subsequent scholarship, teaching, and policy. In so doing, they elucidate a crucial problem of the criminal justice system: how to decide when discretion is needed and when it must be constrained if the system is to enhance efficiency and avoid injustice."-- Richard D. Schwartz, Syracuse University College of Law

Contributors include Herman Goldstein, Walter J. Dickey, Raymond I. Parnas, Wayne R. LaFave, and Donald J. Newman.

Lloyd E. Ohlin is Touroff-Glueck Professor of Criminal Justice Emeritus at Harvard Law School. Frank J. Remington is Professor of Law at the University of Wisconsin Law School.

Bookmark and Share

Table of Contents


Foreword by Michael Tonry

1. Surveying Discretion by Criminal Justice Decision Makers
Lloyd E. Ohlin

The American Bar Foundation Survey

The Survey Origins
Research Methodology
Major Observations of the Survey

The Pilot Project Reports and the Survey Books
The Impact of Ideology on Practice and Research
Policy Choices

2. Confronting the Complexity of the Policing Function
Herman Goldstein

The State of Knowledge Before the ABF Survey
The American Bar Foundation Survey

Substantive Findings

Developments Since the ABF Survey

The Varied Nature of the Police Function
The Infinite Variety of Situations Police Are Called on to Handle
The Varied Uses of Arrest
The Prevalence of Discretion on Policing
The Police Decision Not to Arrest
The Criminal Justice System as a System


3. The Decision to Charge, the Decision to Convict on a Plea of Guilty, and the Impact of Sentence Structure on Prosecution Practices
Frank J. Remington

The Charging and Guilty Plea Decisions as Seen in the Pre-ABF Research

The Charging Decision
The Guilty Plea Decision

The Charging and Guilty Plea Decisions in the ABF Research

The Charging Decision
The Guilty Plea Decision
Lessons Learned in the ABF Research on Charging and Guilty Plea Decisions

Post-ABF Developments

The Charging Decision
The Guilty Plea Decision
The Changing of Roles of Trial Judge, Prosecuter, Defense Counsel, and Victim in the Charging and Guilty Plea Decisions


4. Sentencing, Parole, and Community Supervision
Walter J. Dickey

Pre-ABF Research and Developments

Classical and Positivist Theories
Implementation of Rehabilitative Theory in American Practices
Ideological Framework of the Pre-ABF Research
Pre-ABF Research Findings
Sentencing Discretion in Pre-ABF Research
Conclusions on Pre-ABF Research

The American Bar Foundation Research

Trial Judge Sentencing in Wisconsin as Described by the ABF Research
Parole Release in Wisconsin
Probation and Parole Supervision in Wisconsin
Significance of the ABF Research

Post-ABF Research and Developments

The Experience in Wisconsin
After the ABF Survey--Sentencing and Parole Release

Conclusion: Discretion in Sentencing and Corrections on the National Scene

5. Criminal Justice Responses to Domestic Violence
Raymond I. Parnas

The ABF Survey's Contribution to Domestic Violence Issues
Related Developments on Domestic Violence Issues
Influences on the Development of Full Enforcement Policies
Research Findings on Full Enforcement
The Future: From Low Visibility to High Visibility; From Adjustment to Arrest; So What?

6. Police Rule Making and the Fourth Amendment: The Role of the Courts
Wayne R. LaFave

Police Rule Making and the Fourth Amendment
Impoundments and Inventories: The Bertine "Standardized Procedure" Requirement
Inspections: The Camera "Reasonable ...Administrative Standards" Requirement
Stops: By "Plan" or By "Profile"
Arrests: Police Limits on Force and Custody
The Role of the Courts to Date
Remaining Problem Areas

7. The American Bar Foundation Survey and the Development of Criminal Justice Higher Education
Donald J. Newman

Criminal Justice Education

Development of Educational Materials
Summer Seminars for Legal and Social Science Scholars
Law Student Summer Field Placements in Criminal Justice Agencies
Problems with Teaching and Researching Criminal Justice in Law School Settings

Creation of the State University of New York and the First School of Criminal Justice

Governor Nelson Rockefeller and the State University of New York
Origins of the School of Criminal Justice at Albany
The Role of Eliot Lumbard
Meeting the Personnel Needs of Criminal Justice Agencies
Early Consultants to the Albany School
The Planning Year: Creation of the Albany Model
Criminal Justice Education Defined
Graduate Curriculum in Criminal Justice: The Albany Model
Structure of the School: Faculty and Student Criteria
The Albany School After Twenty Years

The Spread of Criminal Justice Higher Education

The Federal Office of Manpower and Training
Criminal Justice Education Proselytizers
The Creation of the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences
Survival After the Demise of LEAA
Location and Identity in Universities and Colleges
Location on New and Secondary Campuses
Why Survival and Growth?

The American Bar Foundation Survey and Criminal Justice Education Today

Major Contributions of the ABF Survey to Criminal Justice Higher Education
Contrary Developments and Unanticipated Consequences in the Academic Field of Criminal Justice

The Future off Criminal Justice Education

Solidifying the Field
Location on Prestigious Campuses
New Student Populations
Curriculum Standardizations
Research Trends
Increased Professionalism of On-Line Personnel


Appendix A: About the Authors

Appendix B: Project Participants


Related Subjects

Related Titles

Mothering from the Inside
Mothering from the Inside
Simple Theory, Hard Reality
Simple Theory, Hard Reality
Campaigns Against Corporal Punishment
Campaigns Against Corporal Punishment
The New Abolitionists
The New Abolitionists
Inventing Criminology
Inventing Criminology
Race and Police Brutality
Race and Police Brutality
Law, Psychology, and Justice
Law, Psychology, and Justice
Prediction in Criminology
Prediction in Criminology
Measuring Crime
Measuring Crime
Crimes by the Capitalist State
Crimes by the Capitalist State