top_2_1.jpg top_2_2.jpg
The Sense of Appropriateness
Application Discourses in Morality and Law
The Sense of Appropriateness
Click on image to enlarge

Klaus Gunther - Author
John Farrell - Translator
SUNY series in Social and Political Thought
Price: $95.00 
Hardcover - 353 pages
Release Date: September 1993
ISBN10: 0-7914-1551-1
ISBN13: 978-0-7914-1551-1

Price: $33.95 
Paperback - 353 pages
Release Date: September 1993
ISBN10: 0-7914-1552-X
ISBN13: 978-0-7914-1552-8

Available as a Google eBook
for other eReaders and tablet devices.
Click icon below...

Summary Read First Chapter image missing

"Does the justification of moral principle or rule of law justify its application to particular cases? This is the issue in Klaus Gunther's The Sense of Appropriateness. It is handled with great skill and critical insight. This is an admirable performance which makes a serious advance in the Frankfurt approach to the study of rational practical discourse." -- D. N. MacCormick, Center for Criminology and the Social and Philosophical Study of Law, The University of Edinburgh

Gunther's book demonstrates that most objections to moral and legal principles are directed not against the validity of principles but against the manner of their application. If one distinguishes between the justification of a principle and its appropriate application, then the claim that the application of the principle in each individual case follows automatically from its universal justification proves to be a misunderstanding. Gunther develops this distinction with the help of Habermas's discourse theory of morality. He then employs it to extend Kohlberg's theory of moral development and to defend this against Gilligan's critique. In the third and fourth parts of the book, Gunther shows--in debate with Hare, Dworkin, and others--how argumentation on the appropriate application of norms and principles in morality and law is possible.

Klaus Gunther is Professor of Law at the University of Frankfurt.

Bookmark and Share

Table of Contents

Translators Introduction

Author's Preface

Author's Introduction

Part One: The Problem of Application in Discourse Ethics

1. Justification and Application on the Presupposition of a Semantic Principle of Universalizability

2. Justification and Application on the Presupposition of the Moral Principle (U)

3. Two Versions of the Universalization Principle

4. Application as Discourse

5. Can Justification Discourses be Replaced by Application Discourses?

6. The Application of the Moral Principle

Part Two: The Problem of the Application of Norms n the Development of Moral Consciousness

1. The "Free Application" of Indeterminate Norms as a Result of Societal Rationalization Processes (Durkheim)

Excursus: The Emergence and Following of Rules in Social Processes

1. The Emergence of Situation-independent Meanings in Social Situations (Mead)

2. Rule-following as a "Custom" (Wittgenstein)

2. Mead's Draft of a Universalist Ethics as a Method for the Constructive Formation of Appropriate Hypotheses

3. The Differentiation Between Justification and Application at the Postconventional Level of Moral Consciousness (Piaget and Kohlberg)

3.1 The Development of the Relation Between Equity and Equality in Piaget

3.2 A Provisional Developmental Scenario

3.3 The Development of the Relation Between Equity and Equality in Kohlberg

4. Is There a Contextualist Alternative to "Stage 6"?—The Discovery that "it depends"

5. Is Postconventional Moral Consciousness Rigoristic?

6. Summary: Three Levels in the Development of Types of Application

Excursus: "Phronesis" as an Example of Context-bound Application

1. The Aristotelian Theory

2. Appropriate Understanding: Hermeneutics

Part Three: Appropriateness Argumentation in Morality

1. The Problem of a Conflict of Norms: Prima Facie and Definitive Norms

2. Appropriateness Argumentation as an Experimental Procedure and as a Moral Learning Process

3. Elements of a Logic of Appropriateness Argumentation

3.1 Complete Description of a Situation

3.2 Norm Coherence

Part Four: Appropriateness Argumentation in Law

1. Discourse Ethics' Reasons for the Distinction Between Law and Morality

2. Systems Theory's Concept of Law

2.1 Double Contingency

2.2 Law as an Autopoietic System: Differentiation into Code and Programming

3. The Indeterminacy of Legal Rules

3.1 Hermeneutical Models

3.2 "Integrity": In Search of the Best Justification (Dworkin)




Related Subjects

Related Titles

Moral Analysis
Moral Analysis
Writing Without Footnotes: The Role of the Medievalist in Contemporary Intellectual Life
Writing Without Footnotes: The Role of the Medievalist in Contemporary Intellectual Life
Rational Spirituality and Divine Virtue in Plato
Rational Spirituality and Divine Virtue in Plato
The Step Not Beyond
The Step Not Beyond
Jean-Luc Nancy and Plural Thinking
Jean-Luc Nancy and Plural Thinking
Inventing the Universe
Inventing the Universe
Res Publica
Res Publica
The Kantian Subject
The Kantian Subject
Heidegger and the Essence of Man
Heidegger and the Essence of Man